Reproducibility of the external surface position in left‐breast DIBH radiotherapy with spirometer‐based monitoring
نویسندگان
چکیده
Deep inspiration breath hold (DIBH) in left-sided breast cancer radiotherapy treatments allows for a reduction in cardiac and pulmonary doses without compromising target coverage. The selection of the most appropriate technology for DIBH monitoring is a crucial issue. We evaluated the stability and reproducibility of DIBHs controlled by a spirometric device, by assessing the variability of the external surface position within a single DIBH (intra-DIBH) and between DIBHs performed in the same treatment session (intrafraction) or in different sessions (interfraction). The study included seven left-breast cancer patients treated with spirometer-based DIBH radiotherapy. Infrared optical tracking was used to record the 3D coordinates of seven to eleven passive markers placed on the patient's thoraco-abdominal surface during 29-43 DIBHs performed in six to eight treatment sessions. The obtained results showed displacements of the external surface between different sessions up to 6.3mm along a single direction, even at constant inspired volumes. The median value of the interfraction variability in the position of breast passive markers was 2.9 mm (range 1.9-4.8 mm) in the latero-lateral direction, 3.6 mm (range 2.2-4.6mm) in the antero-posterior direction, and 4.3mm (range 2.8-6.2 mm) in the cranio-caudal direction. There were no significant dose distribution variations for target and organs at risk with respect to the treatment plan, confirming the adequacy of the applied clinical margins (15 mm) to compensate for the measured setup uncertainties. This study demonstrates that spirometer-based control does not guarantee a stable and reproducible position of the external surface in left-breast DIBH radiotherapy, suggesting the need for more robust DIBH monitoring techniques when reduced margins and setup uncertainties are required for improving normal tissue sparing and decreasing cardiac and pulmonary toxicity.
منابع مشابه
Reproducibility of the external surface position in left‐breast DIBH radiotherapy with spirometer‐based monitoring: methodological mistake
Dear Editor, I was interested to read the papers by Fassi and colleagues, published in the January 2014 issue of Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics (JACMP).(1) The authors aimed to evaluated the reproducibility of deep inspiration breath hold (DIBHs) controlled by a spirometric device, by assessing the variability of the external surface position within a single DIBH (intra-DIBH) and b...
متن کاملResponse to: Reproducibility of the external surface position in left‐breast DIBH radiotherapy with spirometer‐based monitoring: methodological mistake
To the Editor: We thank Siamak Sabour for his interest in our recently published manuscript.(1) Our study was focused on the assessment of the reproducibility of the external surface position in repeated DIBHs controlled by a spirometric device. Patient surface data were obtained from an infrared (IR) optoelectronic localizer. Results were reported in terms of variability of the optically track...
متن کاملImproving Intra-Fractional Target Position Accuracy Using a 3D Surface Surrogate for Left Breast Irradiation Using the Respiratory-Gated Deep-Inspiration Breath-Hold Technique
PURPOSE To evaluate the use of 3D optical surface imaging as a surrogate for respiratory gated deep-inspiration breath-hold (DIBH) for left breast irradiation. MATERIAL AND METHODS Patients with left-sided breast cancer treated with lumpectomy or mastectomy were selected as candidates for DIBH treatment for their external beam radiation therapy. Treatment plans were created on both free breat...
متن کاملA Comparative Study of 3-D Conformal Radiotherapy Treatment Plans with and Without Deep Inspiration Breath-Hold Technique for Left-Sided Breast Cancer
Introduction: The rate of cardiac diseases have increased among patients who underwent radiotherapy for left-sided breast cancer. The study’s aim was evaluate the dose to organs at risk in free-breathing 3-dimensional conformal (FB-3DCRT) against 3-dimensional conformal deep inspiration breath-hold (3DCRT-DIBH) in patients with left-sided breast cancer. Ma...
متن کاملClinical experience using a video‐guided spirometry system for deep inhalation breath‐hold radiotherapy of left‐sided breast cancer
The purpose was to report clinical experience of a video-guided spirometry system in applying deep inhalation breath-hold (DIBH) radiotherapy for left-sided breast cancer, and to study the systematic and random uncertainties, intra- and interfraction motion and impact on cardiac dose associated with DIBH. The data from 28 left-sided breast cancer patients treated with spirometer-guided DIBH rad...
متن کامل